Quick Review (read on for full review)
I thought I would enjoy this book so much more than I did, but alas, I didn’t. If I’d read it as a child, which I hadn’t, I wonder if I might have enjoyed it a little more…1 / 5
Summary (from Goodreads)
Katy Carr intends to be beautiful and beloved and as sweet as an angel one day. For now, though, her hair is forever in a tangle, her dress is always torn and she doesn’t care at all for being called ‘good’. But then a terrible accident happens and Katy must find the courage to remember her daydreams and the delightful plans she once schemed; for when she is grown up she wants to do something grand…
“To-morrow I will begin,” thought Katy, as she dropped asleep that night. How often we all do so! And what a pity it is that when morning comes and to-morrow is to-day, we so frequently wake up feeling quite differently; careless or impatient, and not a bit inclined to do the fine things we planned overnight.”
(From What Katy Did by Susan Coolidge)
I’ve not got many good things to say about this book, and I’m quite disappointed by that, especially after liking my revisit of The Secret Garden. I had high hopes for this, given its popularity. Growing up, I recall it was a favourite of a number of friends, and I was often encouraged to read it by family and friends and teachers but I was too preoccupied with other books of my own choosing to do so. I preferred mysteries, horror and crime stories, even then. 😉
The main problem I found was it came across as a little dated. It’s very much a product of its time and lacks the timelessness of Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women in comparison (which, is another book I’m hoping to re-read soon). Little girls should be good, pretty, obedient, well-presented…you get the idea. There were also a few troubling passages in the book that I couldn’t help but feel uncomfortable with, such as views on disability and what it is to be a good person.
It didn’t help that I didn’t like Katy very much. I found her annoying and frustrating. At one point in the story, I actually gasped in shock at something she had done – I’ll not mention here for fear of spoilers, though I’ll happily discuss it in the comments, should anyone wish to. The only words to describe it: terrible and harrowing.
I felt a lot of sympathy towards Aunt Izzy, though I can imagine, reading this as a child, I too would have seen her as the enemy of all things fun. The perspective of age here plays its part.
I do wonder if I had read it as a child – and if I had liked it then – I might have enjoyed it more now. Revisiting it with fond recollections might have made me more amenable to Katy and better able to tolerate the things about her that I didn’t like. Of course, it is worth pointing out it’s a children’s story and not being a child, I am not the intended target audience for this book.
Only after writing the first draft of my review did I learn, on reading other reviews on Goodreads, that the title of the book is in fact a play on the name of a family of insects (katydid). Which explains the opening of the story, something I did not get at all at the time. So I come away from this book having learned something – always good!
Will I be reading more from the Carr series of story by Susan Coolidge? The next book is What Katy Did At School. My answer: Not any time soon…
Just a note: I listened to an audio dramatization of this book from LibreVox. The dramatization was well done, but it was the story itself that I didn’t like – I just want to make that clear. As I mentioned when reviewing The Secret Garden, finding favourite quotes is harder to do for an audiobook compared to having the text in front of you. So I cheated a little and searched the ones listed on Goodreads, but only picked one that I could actually recall.
Sammi Loves Books Reading Challenge 2019 – I’ve chosen this book for challenge #20 in the list: a book written by an author that has the same initials as you